1. This looks pretty interesting. The narrator sounds uber-pretentious, but the entire idea behind it is a solid one. I'll definitely give it a rent when it's released. Is this YET ANOTHER 360 exclusive?

Posted at 1:35AM on Sep 21st 2006 by Xavier 0 stars

2. After all I've read about Bioshock I wasn't convinced this could be a compelling game.

Happily I stand corrected. This looks pretty sweet I must say!

Posted at 1:35AM on Sep 21st 2006 by james f. 0 stars

3. Wow, looks great. Except for those hideous UI icons. I really hope those aren't final for the game. Such an eyesore over a gourgeous environment.

Posted at 2:03AM on Sep 21st 2006 by Les Doodis 0 stars

4. That video looks amazing!

Posted at 2:22AM on Sep 21st 2006 by Bryan Thumme 0 stars

5. Cliche I hope they avoid: exploding barrels/crates/boxes/whatever.

Should be pretty easy considering it's set underwater, but that's what I thought about Doom 3 and Mars...

Posted at 2:30AM on Sep 21st 2006 by plaidspeed 0 stars

6. They've still got 2 FPS cliches there: guns, enemies and the first-person perspective.

I want a third-person swords-only FPS with noone to fight. That's called innovation!

Posted at 6:16AM on Sep 21st 2006 by Azerael 0 stars

7. I win at numbers.

=B

Posted at 6:19AM on Sep 21st 2006 by Azerael 0 stars

8. I love the style of art and story thus far. I'm really looking forward to playing it.

Posted at 9:57AM on Sep 21st 2006 by beardsly43 0 stars

9. I was waiting for a gameplay video to decide whether I was truly interested in this game. this has definately sealed the deal. The atmosphere, the tone, my god THE WATER EFFECTS! It's all so engrossing.

Posted at 11:15AM on Sep 21st 2006 by footlong! 0 stars

10. Care to explain why the picture link leads to some stupid myspace page?

Posted at 1:52AM on Sep 21st 2006 by Jason 0 stars

11. Hmmm... maybe it's the narrator, but I was hoping to be more blown-away than this. Yes the art is gorgeous, but it still get a little feeling of, "real-time weapons switching!"

That is, there are nice innovations but not a HUGE leap forward from say, Half-Life 2. I mean, HL2 had very stylized universe and antagonists that you could later use for protection (Antlion bugbait), and lots of games have genetic modifications.

Entirely 'non-scripted' is pretty ambitious though - could be a huge selling point.

Posted at 2:27PM on Sep 21st 2006 by intRvenous 0 stars

12. This game just looks better and better... It almost looks like a mix between Condemned (one of my favorite games) and Deus Ex (another great game).

I don't know how much longer I can wait for it.

Posted at 9:39AM on Sep 21st 2006 by ragtimepianist 0 stars

13. OH, I second the "hideous UI icons" motion. PLEASE DO BETTER ICONS.

I couldn't put my finger on it at first, but something looked horribly out-of-place...

Posted at 2:34PM on Sep 21st 2006 by intRvenous 0 stars